| Trans-Siberian Orchestra - Christmas / Sarajevo 12/24 (Instrumental) | 14 |
| Passion Worship Band - Fairest, Lord Jesus | 8 |
| Mannheim Steamroller - It Came Upon The Midnight Clear | 5 |
| Bebo Norman - Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | 5 |
| Jimmy Needham - The Benediction | 5 |
| Jimmy Needham - The Gospel | 5 |
| Frank Sinatra - The Christmas Song | 4 |
| Hanson - White Christmas | 4 |
| Frank Sinatra - Silent Night | 4 |
| Jon McLaughlin - So Close | 3 |
| Harry Connick, Jr. - I'll Be Home for Christmas | 3 |
| Relient K - I Hate Christmas Parties | 2 |
| Mariah Carey - Joy To The World | 2 |
| Robert Randolph and The Family Band - Ain't Nothing Wrong With That | 2 |
| Ingrid Michaelson - Keep Breathing | 2 |
| Kendall Payne - I Will Show You Love | 2 |
| James Taylor - In The Bleak Midwinter | 2 |
| Mariah Carey - All I Want for Christmas Is You | 2 |
| The Brian Setzer Orchestra - (Everybody's Waiting For) The Man With The Bag | 2 |
| Frank Sinatra - Jingle Bells | 2 |
| Mandisa - Christmas Makes Me Cry | 2 |
| Bing Crosby - The Little Drummer Boy | 2 |
| John Legend - Sun Comes Up | 1 |
| John Butler Trio - Better Than | 1 |
| Mariah Carey - Jesus Oh What A Wonderful Child | 1 |
| Boyz II Men - In The Still Of The Night (I'll Remember) | 1 |
| MxPx - Secret Weapon | 1 |
| Relient K - Handel's Messiah (The Hallelujah Chorus) | 1 |
| Mariah Carey - Miss You Most (At Christmas Time) | 1 |
| Boyz II Men - On Bended Knee | 1 |
| Cyndi Lauper - You've Really Got a Hold on Me | 1 |
| 33Miles - Stand Amazed | 1 |
| Jennifer Knapp - By And By | 1 |
| Switchfoot - Bomb | 1 |
| Joy Williams - Here With Us (digital single) | 1 |
| DecembeRadio - Drifter | 1 |
| 'N Sync - I Never Knew the Meaning of Christmas | 1 |
| 'N Sync - I Guess It's Christmas Time | 1 |
| Boyz II Men & LL Cool J - Hey Lover (w / LL Cool J) | 1 |
| A Dream Too Late - Intermission to the Moon | 1 |
| After Edmund - afteredmun_clouds.bounce | 1 |
| Between The Trees - BTTwayshefeelsedit | 1 |
| Matt Wertz - mattwertz_caroline | 1 |
| Matt Wertz - mattwertz_519 | 1 |
| newworldson - Salvation Station | 1 |
| Ray Charles - Lift Every Voice And Sing [bonus] | 1 |
| Bing Crosby - Let in Snow | 1 |
| Enter the Worship Circle - I Will Not Forget You (Psalm 50) | 1 |
| Phil Wickham - The Light Will Come | 1 |
| Phil Wickham - Sailing On A Ship | 1 |
