| Tegan and Sara - The Con | 568 |
| Tegan and Sara - So Jealous | 369 |
| Sufjan Stevens - Illinoise | 278 |
| Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend | 235 |
| Kaki King - Dreaming Of Revenge | 183 |
| Destroyer - Notorious Lightning and Other Works | 182 |
| Tegan and Sara - If It Was You | 178 |
| Regina Spektor - Begin to Hope | 167 |
| Tegan and Sara - This Business of Art | 156 |
| Alela Diane - The Pirate's Gospel | 147 |
| Bright Eyes - Cassadaga | 143 |
| Northern State - Can I Keep This Pen? | 139 |
| The Weepies - Say I Am You | 136 |
| Björk - Björk's Greatest Hits | 133 |
| Against Me! - New Wave | 129 |
| Sufjan Stevens - The Avalanche - Outtakes and Extras from the Illinois Album | 126 |
| Moshav - Misplaced | 116 |
| Matisyahu - Youth | 113 |
| Death Cab For Cutie - Plans | 110 |
| Death Cab For Cutie - Death Cab For Cutie | 109 |
| The Postal Service - Give Up | 109 |
| The Be Good Tanyas - Hello Love | 103 |
| Jack's Mannequin - Everything In Transit | 102 |
| Radiohead - OK Computer | 101 |
| Feist - The Reminder | 100 |
| The Moth - The Moth Podcast | 98 |
| The Killers - Sam's Town | 98 |
| The Bird and the Bee - The Bird And The Bee | 93 |
| Mariee Sioux - Faces In The Rocks | 92 |
| Rilo Kiley - Under the Blacklight | 89 |
| Kimya Dawson - Juno (Music from the Motion Picture) | 87 |
| Ani DiFranco - Educated Guess | 86 |
| Kimya Dawson - Remember That I Love You | 84 |
| Tina Dico - Live Session (iTunes Exclusive) - EP | 82 |
| Ani DiFranco - Knuckle Down | 81 |
| That 1 Guy - The Moon Is Disgusting | 77 |
| Imogen Heap - Speak For Yourself | 75 |
| The Radio - Grey's Anatomy (Original Soundtrack) | 74 |
| Tilly and the Wall - Bottoms of Barrels | 71 |
| Chicago Public Radio - This American Life | 68 |
| Devendra Banhart - Rejoicing In The Hands | 66 |
| Bright Eyes - I'm Wide Awake It's Morning | 65 |
| Coconut Records - Nighttiming | 65 |
| Get Set Go - Fourth Record | 64 |
| Ani DiFranco - Evolve | 59 |
| The Innocence Mission - Birds Of My Neighborhood | 57 |
| Mayday Parade - Punk Goes Acoustic, Vol. 2 | 55 |
| Scientific American - 60-Second Psych | 55 |
| Tegan & Sara - I'll Take the Blame - EP | 54 |
| Kaki King - Everybody Loves You | 54 |
