| Sufjan Stevens - O Come O Come Emmanuel | 8 |
| Switchfoot - Stars | 6 |
| Shane & Shane - Yearn | 6 |
| Sufjan Stevens - Come Thou Fount Of Every Blessing | 6 |
| Steven Curtis CHapman - O Come All Ye Faithful | 6 |
| Various - Majestic (Lincoln Brewster) | 6 |
| Third Day - Silent Night | 5 |
| Shane & Shane - I Want It All | 5 |
| Sufjan Stevens - Joy To The World | 5 |
| U2 - Grace | 5 |
| Sufjan Stevens - O Holy Night | 5 |
| Sufjan Stevens - Angels We Have Heard On High | 5 |
| Tammany Hall Nyc - Cindy | 5 |
| Sufjan Stevens - The First Noel | 5 |
| Third Day - Away In A Manger | 5 |
| Various - Rescue (Jared Anderson) | 5 |
| Shane & Shane - Beauty For Ashes | 4 |
| Sister Hazel - Hold On | 4 |
| Glen Hansard - All the way down | 4 |
| Chris Rice - It is Well With My Soul | 4 |
| Switchfoot - Happy Is a Yuppie Word | 4 |
| The Juliana Theory - Everything | 4 |
| Chris Rice - Rock of Ages | 4 |
| Switchfoot - Lonely Nation | 4 |
| The Juliana Theory - Into The Dark | 4 |
| Shane & Shane - Make Believe Jesus | 4 |
| Glen Hansard & Marketa Irglova - If You Want Me | 4 |
| Glen Hansard - Say It To Me Now | 4 |
| Glen Hansard & Marketa Irglova - Falling Slowly | 4 |
| Chris Rice - O Freedom | 4 |
| Chris Rice - O Love That Will Not Let Me Go | 4 |
| Chris Rice - Great Is Thy Faithfulness | 4 |
| Sufjan Stevens - Once In Royal David’s City | 4 |
| Glen Hansard & Marketa Irglova - When Your Mind's Made Up | 4 |
| Chris Rice - The Old Rugged Cross | 4 |
| Chris Rice - A Mighty Fortress Is Our God | 4 |
| Glen Hansard - Trying to Pull Myself Away | 4 |
| Various - Rain Down (David Crowder) | 4 |
| U2 - Kite | 3 |
| Vince Guaraldi Trio - O Tannenbaum | 3 |
| Switchfoot - Golden | 3 |
| Shane & Shane - When I Think About the Lord | 3 |
| Shane & Shane - Song of Surrender | 3 |
| Shane & Shane - Your Grace is Sufficient | 3 |
| Shane & Shane - He is Exalted | 3 |
| Shane & Shane - Fringes | 3 |
| Shane & Shane - You and I | 3 |
| Shane Barnard & Shane Everett - Psalm 13 | 3 |
| Maroon 5 - Intro | 3 |
| U2 - Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own | 3 |
