| Sufjan Stevens - Sufjan Stevens: Songs for Christmas | 73 |
| Glen Hansard - Once (Music from the Motion Picture) | 41 |
| Third Day - Christmas Offerings | 39 |
| Various - Worship in the Park | 39 |
| Switchfoot - Nothing Is Sound | 39 |
| Chris Rice - Peace Like a River: The Hymns Project | 38 |
| The Juliana Theory - Love | 37 |
| They Might Be Giants - Flood | 37 |
| Shane & Shane - Clean | 34 |
| U2 - All That You Can't Leave Behind | 34 |
| They Might Be Giants - No! | 33 |
| Shane & Shane - Carry Away | 33 |
| Ricardo Lemvo & Makina Loca - Baila - A Latin Dance Party | 33 |
| Jamiroquai - Travelling Without Moving | 26 |
| Salvador - Qué Tan Lejos Está El Cielo | 26 |
| U2 - How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb | 25 |
| Stricken - Dawn Breaking | 24 |
| SONICFLOOd - Sonicflood | 23 |
| The Chieftains - Down The Old Plank Road: The Nashville Sessions | 23 |
| Phish - Farmhouse | 23 |
| Switchfoot - The Beautiful Letdown | 22 |
| Shane & Shane - Upstairs | 20 |
| Third Day - Come Together | 20 |
| David Crowder Band - Illuminate | 19 |
| Spoon - Gimme Fiction | 19 |
| Béla Fleck - Daybreak | 18 |
| Caedmon's Call - Share The Well | 18 |
| Steadman - Loser Friendly | 16 |
| P.O.D. - The Fundamental Elements of Southtown | 16 |
| OK Go - Oh No | 14 |
| Jason Mraz - Tonight, Not Again / Live at Eagles Ballroom | 14 |
| Sparta - Porcelain | 14 |
| Jackson Waters - All That I Know | 14 |
| Michel Camilo - MICHEL CAMILO | 14 |
| Ben Folds Five - Whatever & Ever Amen | 14 |
| Incubus - A Crow Left Of The Murder... | 14 |
| Norah Jones - Come Away With Me | 14 |
| Vanessa Carlton - Be Not Nobody | 13 |
| Ben Folds - Rockin' The Suburbs | 13 |
| Sister Hazel - Lift | 13 |
| John Mayer - Room for Squares | 13 |
| Steven Curtis CHapman - Signs Of Life | 13 |
| Gavin DeGraw - Chariot Stripped [Bonus Disc] | 13 |
| The Juliana Theory - Emotion Is Dead | 13 |
| Dave Matthews Band - Busted Stuff | 12 |
| Steadman - Revive | 12 |
| Maroon 5 - Songs About Jane | 12 |
| Chris Thile - Not All Who Wander Are Lost | 12 |
| Sparta - Wiretap Scars | 12 |
| Coldplay - X&Y | 12 |
