| Vampire Weekend - Cape Cod Kwassa Kwassa | 20 |
| Vampire Weekend - Oxford Comma | 19 |
| Okkervil River - Our Life Is Not a Movie or Maybe | 18 |
| Vampire Weekend - A-Punk | 17 |
| Okkervil River - Unless It's Kicks | 17 |
| Okkervil River - A Hand To Take Hold Of The Scene | 16 |
| Okkervil River - Savannah Smiles | 14 |
| The Mountain Goats - This Year | 12 |
| Okkervil River - Plus Ones | 12 |
| Okkervil River - A Girl In Port | 12 |
| The New Pornographers - Mass Romantic | 11 |
| The Magnetic Fields - I Think I Need A New Heart | 11 |
| The Magnetic Fields - The Book of Love | 10 |
| The New Pornographers - Jackie | 10 |
| The New Pornographers - Mystery Hours | 10 |
| The New Pornographers - The Slow Descent Into Alcoholism | 10 |
| Vampire Weekend - Mansard Roof | 10 |
| Vampire Weekend - Campus | 10 |
| Vampire Weekend - Bryn | 10 |
| Okkervil River - You Can't Hold The Hand Of A Rock And Roll Man | 10 |
| Okkervil River - (Shannon Wilsey On The) Starry Stairs [Bonus Track] | 10 |
| Vampire Weekend - I Stand Corrected | 10 |
| Vampire Weekend - M79 | 10 |
| Okkervil River - Title Track | 9 |
| Girl Talk - Hold Up | 9 |
| Magnetic Fields - The Luckiest Guy On The Lower East Side | 9 |
| Silver Jews - punks in the beerlight | 9 |
| Spoon - Everything Hits At Once | 9 |
| The New Pornographers - The Fake Headlines | 9 |
| Magnetic Fields - Parades Go By | 9 |
| YACHT - We're Always Waiting | 9 |
| Vampire Weekend - Walcott | 9 |
| Okkervil River - John Allyn Smith Sails | 9 |
| Band Of Horses - The Funeral | 8 |
| Band Of Horses - The First Song | 8 |
| The Mountain Goats - Up The Wolves | 8 |
| The Mountain Goats - You Or Your Memory | 8 |
| The Mountain Goats - Dilaudid | 8 |
| Silver Jews - the poor, the fair and the good | 8 |
| Silver Jews - animal shapes | 8 |
| Spoon - Me and the Bean | 8 |
| Magnetic Fields - Punk Love | 8 |
| The New Pornographers - Letter From An Occupant | 8 |
| The New Pornographers - To Wild Homes | 8 |
| Jens Lekman - Maple Leaves | 8 |
| Magnetic Fields - The One You Really Love | 8 |
| Magnetic Fields - How Fucking Romantic | 8 |
| Magnetic Fields - Boa Constrictor | 8 |
| Magnetic Fields - A Chicken With Its Head Cut Off | 8 |
| Magnetic Fields - Reno Dakota | 8 |
